The Green Retreat

Why Wall Street's ESG flip-flop demands a new economic vision

Just as we were led to believe Wall Street was beginning to embrace sustainability, major players are backpedaling. JPMorgan, BlackRock, and others are abandoning their climate pledges. What does this say about the future of finance? For impact practitioners, this retreat sends a stark message: profit-driven financial institutions cannot be relied upon to create a truly sustainable world.

Recent movements by some of the world’s leading financial institutions signal a troubling, though not entirely surprising, retreat from their once-vocal commitments to climate action and Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) principles. This trend, epitomized by the withdrawal of JPMorgan, State Street, and Pimco from Climate Action 100+, along with BlackRock and Bank of America’s scaling back on climate initiatives, might come as a disillusionment to many. Yet, for those of us who have been entrenched in the climate movement for decades, this pattern of advance and retreat is all too familiar.

Historically, as the climate movement gained traction, successes were often met with stiff opposition from entrenched interests such as fossil fuel companies, large-scale agribusiness, and mining corporations. These sectors, whose fortunes are deeply interwoven with the extractivist capitalist system, have found allies in right-wing politicians. Such politicians, bereft of progressive policy ideas, have weaponized ESG, framing it as an enemy to the traditional economic order they seek to preserve.

Globe in front of city

This backlash is not merely a political skirmish; it reveals the fragility of corporate commitments to sustainability. The recent backtracking suggests that many firms’ pledges were more a matter of convenience than conviction, superficial measures that could be easily discarded when faced with political pressure or legal risk. As the New York Times reported, this phenomenon underscores a critical truth: transformative change is nearly impossible from within a system that remains anchored to a single bottom line ethos.

Real-World Impact Beyond Greenwashing

For impact practitioners, the implications are clear. Take a hypothetical impact enterprise, ‘Good Seed Organic Farms’. Their soil-enriching methods promise long-term land health but they struggle to secure traditional loans based on short-term profitability projections. Only by partnering with an impact investment fund are they able to scale their regenerative practices. These are the real-world consequences when finance remains fixated on traditional metrics of financial returns.

If sustainability pledges can be dropped when inconvenient, can they ever be a catalyst for the change we need?

It’s worth noting that many of the firms backpedaling on ESG were signatories to high-profile initiatives like The Net-Zero Banking Alliance. This contradiction exposes the gap between branding and concrete action. If sustainability pledges can be dropped when inconvenient, can they ever be a catalyst for the change we need?

Finance must reflect the world we want to build, not just the world we have. Until investors truly value environmental and social returns alongside financial ones, sustainability will remain elusive.

Redefining Capitalism for an Impact Economy

For a transformation towards a truly impact-driven economy, we must look beyond traditional financial actors. The future lies in the hands of impact businesses — entities like Public Benefit Corporations and B Corps — that embody social and environmental impact in their DNA. It necessitates a fundamental reconstruction of the finance sector itself, one that embeds a triple bottom line into its core. Let’s move beyond simply ‘greening’ existing financial products and create innovative ways to direct capital toward initiatives that prioritize people, planet, and profit.

We also need a supportive policy environment. Clear regulations that enable financial institutions to integrate ESG factors without fear of legal repercussions are crucial. Advocacy to educate stakeholders about the benefits of a triple bottom line approach is vital. For example, standardized ESG reporting frameworks and tax breaks for sustainable investments can incentivize financial institutions to prioritize long-term environmental and social impact alongside financial returns. Additionally, advocating for the removal of fossil fuel subsidies and implementing carbon pricing mechanisms can create a level playing field that disadvantages unsustainable practices.

Oil wells in barren landscape

Examples of the potential for transformative change abound. Consider the rise of renewable energy or the market for sustainable agriculture. These shifts have occurred despite political pushback, thanks in part to forward-thinking investors. Now is the time to amplify these models.

Let the current setbacks be a reminder that the path to sustainability is fraught with challenges. Yet, true change will emerge from innovative, impact-driven businesses and those who finance them. The journey towards an Impact Economy demands perseverance, innovation, and unwavering commitment.

Impact entrepreneurs, your resolve makes a difference! Seek partners whose profit motives don’t compromise your impact mission. Find financial allies who recognize that the triple bottom line IS the pathway to the future. Together, we can redefine capitalism, turning away from extraction and towards a model where finance serves the greater good.

In this endeavor, Impact Entrepreneur stands as a beacon. Let us forge ahead, undeterred by setbacks, driven by the knowledge that we are building not just an economy, but a legacy for future generations.

Laurie Lane-Zucker is Founder and President of Impact Entrepreneur, a public benefit corporation and impact economy business that hosts the Impact Entrepreneur Network — a large, global network of “systems-minded” entrepreneurs, investors and scholars of social and environmental innovation — and publishes Impact Entrepreneur Magazine. For over 30 years, Laurie ... Read more
NEIII Impact Investing Fellowship Fall 2024

Related Content



Submit a Comment

Impact Entrepreneur Premium Members get full, priority access to ValuesAdvisor. A curated database of values-aligned financial advisors.

Deep Dives


Editor's Picks


News & Events

Subscribe to our newsletter.

Subscribe to our newsletter to receive updates about new Magazine content and upcoming webinars, deep dives, and events.

Access all of Impact Entrepreneur.

Become a Premium Member to access the full library of webinars and deep dives, exclusive membership portal, member directory, message board, and curated live chats.

ie frog
Impact Entrepreneur